Elasticsearch Error: Wildcard query too broad (performance impact) - Common Causes & Fixes

Brief Explanation

This error occurs when an Elasticsearch wildcard query is deemed too broad, potentially causing significant performance issues. Elasticsearch raises this error to prevent queries that could negatively impact the cluster's performance or consume excessive resources.

Impact

This error can have a severe impact on the performance of your Elasticsearch cluster. It may lead to:

  • Slow query response times
  • High CPU and memory usage
  • Potential cluster instability
  • Timeouts or failed queries

Common Causes

  1. Using leading wildcards (e.g., "*text")
  2. Using wildcards with very short prefixes (e.g., "a*")
  3. Applying wildcards to high-cardinality fields
  4. Insufficient hardware resources to handle the query load

Troubleshooting and Resolution

  1. Analyze the query:

    • Identify which part of the query is using wildcards
    • Check if the wildcard is necessary or if it can be replaced with a more specific term
  2. Optimize the query:

    • Avoid leading wildcards
    • Use longer prefixes before wildcards
    • Consider using ngram or edge_ngram tokenizers for prefix matching
  3. Review field mappings:

    • Ensure fields are properly analyzed and indexed
    • Consider using keyword fields for exact matching
  4. Implement query alternatives:

    • Use match_phrase_prefix for prefix matching
    • Utilize completion suggester for autocomplete functionality
  5. Adjust cluster settings:

    • Increase search.allow_expensive_queries setting if necessary
    • Configure `search.max_buckets` to limit the number of matching documents
  6. Monitor and optimize cluster resources:

    • Ensure adequate CPU, memory, and disk resources
    • Consider scaling the cluster if needed

Best Practices

  1. Use wildcards sparingly and strategically
  2. Implement proper indexing strategies for fields that require prefix or suffix matching
  3. Utilize Elasticsearch's analysis features to optimize text searching
  4. Regularly monitor query performance and optimize as needed
  5. Consider implementing a search-as-you-type solution for better user experience and performance

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I completely disable wildcard queries in Elasticsearch?
A: While you can't completely disable wildcard queries, you can set search.allow_expensive_queries to false to prevent potentially expensive queries, including broad wildcard queries.

Q: How do I optimize a wildcard query for better performance?
A: To optimize a wildcard query, use longer prefixes, avoid leading wildcards, consider using ngram or edge_ngram tokenizers, and ensure proper field mappings and analysis.

Q: What are alternatives to wildcard queries for prefix matching?
A: Alternatives include using match_phrase_prefix queries, completion suggesters, or implementing custom analyzers with edge_ngram tokenizers.

Q: How does the search.allow_expensive_queries setting affect wildcard queries?
A: When set to false, this setting prevents execution of queries deemed too expensive, including broad wildcard queries that could impact performance.

Q: Can indexing strategies help mitigate wildcard query performance issues?
A: Yes, proper indexing strategies such as using keyword fields for exact matching and implementing appropriate analyzers can significantly improve wildcard query performance.

Pulse - Elasticsearch Operations Done Right
Free Health Assessment

Need more help with your cluster?

Subscribe to the Pulse Newsletter

Get early access to new Pulse features, insightful blogs & exclusive events , webinars, and workshops.