Elasticsearch Error: Aggregation results exceed memory limits - Common Causes & Fixes

Brief Explanation

This error occurs when an aggregation operation in Elasticsearch consumes more memory than the allocated limit. It's a protective measure to prevent aggregations from using excessive resources and potentially crashing the cluster.

Common Causes

  1. Executing aggregations on high-cardinality fields
  2. Running multiple nested aggregations
  3. Insufficient memory allocation for aggregations
  4. Large dataset size relative to available memory
  5. Poorly optimized aggregation queries

Troubleshooting and Resolution Steps

  1. Increase Circuit Breaker Limits: Adjust the indices.breaker.request.limit setting in elasticsearch.yml. However, use caution as this may lead to out-of-memory errors if set too high.

    indices.breaker.request.limit: 60%
    
  2. Optimize Aggregation Queries:

    • Use filters to reduce the dataset before aggregating
    • Limit the number of buckets in terms aggregations
    • Use more efficient aggregation types when possible
  3. Implement Pagination: Use the composite aggregation for pagination of large result sets.

  4. Increase Node Memory: If possible, allocate more memory to Elasticsearch nodes.

  5. Use Sampling: For approximate results on large datasets, consider using sampling techniques.

  6. Monitor and Analyze: Use Elasticsearch's monitoring tools to identify resource-intensive queries and optimize them.

Additional Information and Best Practices

  • Regularly monitor your cluster's performance and resource usage
  • Use the Elasticsearch Profile API to analyze query performance
  • Consider using async search for long-running aggregations
  • Implement proper data modeling and indexing strategies to support your aggregation needs
  • Use date histograms with appropriate intervals to reduce bucket counts

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can increasing the heap size solve this error?
A: While increasing heap size can help, it's not always the best solution. It's crucial to optimize queries and use efficient aggregation strategies first. Increasing heap size should be considered as a last resort.

Q: How can I identify which aggregations are causing this error?
A: Enable slow logs for search queries and monitor the Elasticsearch logs. You can also use tools like Kibana's Query Profiler or third-party monitoring solutions to identify resource-intensive aggregations.

Q: Are there any alternatives to using large aggregations in Elasticsearch?
A: Yes, consider using pre-aggregated data, implementing a separate analytics database, or using approximate aggregations like HyperLogLog++ for high-cardinality fields.

Q: How does the circuit breaker work in Elasticsearch?
A: The circuit breaker estimates memory usage of operations and stops them if they exceed configured limits. It helps prevent out-of-memory errors that could crash Elasticsearch nodes.

Q: Can this error occur even with small datasets?
A: Yes, if the aggregations are complex or nested, or if they're run on high-cardinality fields, this error can occur even with relatively small datasets.

Pulse - Elasticsearch Operations Done Right
Free Health Assessment

Need more help with your cluster?

Subscribe to the Pulse Newsletter

Get early access to new Pulse features, insightful blogs & exclusive events , webinars, and workshops.